Influence, Christianity and Michael Tait: How Do We Respond When Our Heroes Fall?

For kids like me who grew up on the front pew of the church, Christian music was a way to feel like I fit in while standing close to my convictions. As a young child, I was only allowed to listen to Christian music—mostly Southern Gospel. When I was finally permitted to explore “secular” music as a tween, my best friend, Kelly, immediately bought me No Doubt’s Tragic Kingdom. My purchase of an Alanis Morissette album followed this. Over the years, my CD collection evolved to include everything from the Backstreet Boys to R.E.M. The summer after my freshman year, however, a friend and I felt convicted, gathered two grocery bags full of CDs, and went outside to smash them all.

From then on, I was a Christian-music-only girl—and I was okay with that. There was something magical about coming of age in the 1990s. For church kids, it was a brief window when a miniature Jesus revolution ushered in vibrant youth groups, compelling reads (Jesus Freaks was my favorite), and a lineup of young, aspirational Christian voices to look up to.

And the music—oh, the music was good. My personal collection was rich with alternative rock, ska and a touch of standard ‘90s pop: Skillet, Bleach, Jars of Clay, The O.C. Supertones, Smalltown Poets, Audio Adrenaline, Plumb, Five Iron Frenzy, Miss Angie, Third Day, Newsboys and the kingpin of Christian music: DC Talk.

Beyond their music, Christian bands became voices for a generation hungry for truth, understanding and visibility in an increasingly lost world. We read their books, heeded their warnings on dating, searched for meaning in their lyrics, and yes—we even bought their T-shirts. Christian musicians were the influencers of our day, inspiring us in our faith and walks with God.

Fast forward 20–30 years, and so much has changed. The world we live in is a very different place. Youth groups are shrinking, Christian music has shifted toward a Contemporary Christian Music (CCM) vibe rather than the alt options we grew up with, and, unfortunately, many of our heroes have stumbled along the way. Several members of the bands I listed above have walked away from biblical truth.

When Heroes Fall

Last week, news broke that longtime Newsboys frontman and former DC Talk member Michael Tait faces several allegations of sexual misconduct and substance abuse following a multi-year investigation. While some claim the allegations are an “open secret” in Nashville’s Christian music circles, plenty of others are shocked. Another hero. Another influencer. Another fallen Christian leader.

When serious allegations like these surface, people cringe. Tait and bands like the Newsboys are ingrained in modern Christian culture. We may have grown up, and the world may look very different, but some foundational elements remain. These figures lead us in worship. They encourage us on social media. They motivate us to live out our faith.

When they stumble, we are crushed, too.

The reality is that there is significant fallout for the Christian community when “one of our own” falters. The alleged victims experience significant trauma, and the world waits for the response of those closest to the fallen, including reactions from the community and the Church as a whole. There are also the organizations the individual has aligned with and the causes they champion. Everything is thrust into an uncomfortable spotlight.

Implications for Organizations

This raises a crucial question for marketers: How do we respond when the influential voices we work with go off-script, break the rules, or—worst of all—commit grievous offenses?

The answer is simple: We embrace the truth.

We should not shy away from allegations, blame potential victims or brush situations under the carpet. We have a duty to cling to the truth (Ephesians 4:25) and to confront our fellow believer with their sin for the purpose of reconciliation (Matthew 18:15–17). We must remember we are called to forgive (Colossians 3:13), though that in no way absolves a person of facing the consequences—legal, moral, ethical or otherwise—of their behavior (Galatians 6:7; Romans 13:1). The bottom line is that we are called to cling to Scripture in our response, seeking the truth of a situation, justice for that situation and healing for everyone involved, especially the victims.

Marketers Responding to Fallen Influencers

For marketers in the Christian space, the fall of an influential person like Michael Tait presents a unique challenge. These figures are not just stars or brand ambassadors; they are often seen as spiritual leaders, their platforms intertwined with faith-based values. When allegations surface, the instinct may be to protect the brand, minimize damage, or distance the organization from the controversy. However, this approach risks prioritizing profit over people, which can erode trust and authenticity—core tenets of both Christianity and effective marketing.

Instead, marketers must lead with integrity. They should be transparent and empathetic. Acknowledging allegations promptly, without defensiveness or deflection, signals a commitment to truth. This might mean pausing campaigns, issuing statements that affirm support for victims or reevaluating partnerships. For example, if a ministry or Christian brand has aligned with a fallen influencer, a clear, compassionate response—rooted in biblical principles like justice and restoration—can maintain credibility. Hiding behind silence or vague PR statements often fuels skepticism and alienates audiences who want victims’ voices to be heard.

Setting aside profit considerations is not easy in a results-driven industry, but it’s essential to prioritize the human element. Victims of misconduct deserve validation and support, not secondary harm from organizational cover-ups. The Christian community, too, needs space to process grief and disillusionment. Marketers can facilitate this by fostering open dialogue, perhaps through forums or social media, where fans can express their hurt, seek guidance and pray with one another. This approach not only honors the humanity of those affected but also aligns with the call to “bear one another’s burdens” (Galatians 6:2).

Moreover, marketers should reflect on the broader implications of platforming influencers. While their reach amplifies messages, it also amplifies their flaws. Vetting processes should prioritize character over charisma, and ongoing accountability should be non-negotiable. When a fall occurs, it’s an opportunity to model grace and justice, showing that redemption is possible but not without responsibility. This balance can inspire trust and demonstrate that faith-based organizations value people over their pocketbooks.

Ultimately, the response to a fallen influencer shapes the narrative for the Church and its witness. Marketers have a pivotal role in ensuring that response reflects Christ’s heart—compassionate, just and truthful. By prioritizing the human over the bottom line, they can help rebuild trust, foster healing and remind the world that Christianity is not about perfect heroes but a perfect Savior.

Explore how your brand can connect with our faith-driven audience through impactful advertising. Contact us today to get started.